Reactive vs. Preventive Maintenance: Key Differences, Pros & Best Practices

Manufacturers rely on equipment efficiency to maintain production, minimize costs, and ensure workplace safety. Two common maintenance strategies—reactive and preventive maintenance—play a crucial role in determining how well an operation can manage asset reliability. But which one is better for long-term success?

What is Reactive vs. Preventive Maintenance?

Reactive Maintenance Meaning & Definition

Reactive maintenance (also known as breakdown maintenance or run-to-failure maintenance) is a strategy where maintenance is performed only after an asset fails. It involves repairing or replacing components when they stop working, rather than performing scheduled servicing.

🔹 Example: A conveyor belt motor burns out, halting production until a technician replaces it.
🔹 Common Industries: Manufacturing, logistics, construction, healthcare, and utilities.

While reactive maintenance is sometimes unavoidable, over-reliance on it leads to high costs, frequent downtime, and operational risks.

Preventive Maintenance Meaning & Definition

Preventive maintenance (PM) is a proactive approach that involves scheduled inspections, servicing, and part replacements to prevent equipment breakdowns. Instead of waiting for failure, this method aims to extend asset lifespan and reduce emergency repairs.

🔹 Example: A technician lubricates conveyor belts every 3 months to prevent unexpected motor failures.
🔹 Common Industries: Manufacturing, aerospace, healthcare, fleet management, and facility maintenance.

Preventive maintenance reduces costly breakdowns, improves equipment reliability, and enhances workplace safety.

Types of Reactive & Preventive Maintenance

Types of Reactive Maintenance

✅ Emergency Reactive Maintenance: Urgent repairs due to safety hazards, regulatory violations, or major production stoppages.
✅ Corrective Reactive Maintenance: Fixing equipment after failure is detected but before it causes serious disruption.
✅ Run-to-Failure Maintenance: Allowing non-critical assets to fail completely before replacing them.
✅ On-Demand Maintenance: Maintenance performed in response to operator reports or sensor alerts.
✅ Planned Reactive Maintenance: Failures deliberately deferred due to budget or resource constraints.

Types of Preventive Maintenance

✅ Time-Based Maintenance (TBM): Servicing performed at fixed intervals (e.g., every 6 months).
✅ Usage-Based Maintenance (UBM): Maintenance triggered by equipment usage (e.g., every 1,000 machine cycles).
✅ Condition-Based Maintenance (CBM): Maintenance scheduled based on real-time condition monitoring.
✅ Predictive Maintenance (PdM): Advanced maintenance using AI and IoT sensors to predict failures before they occur.

Reactive vs. Preventive Safety: A Clear Difference

Reactive Safety: Addressing Risks After an Incident

Reactive safety measures come into play after an accident, equipment failure, or workplace hazard has already caused damage. This approach relies on investigating incidents, identifying the cause, and implementing corrective actions to prevent recurrence.

Example in Manufacturing: A machine operator suffers an injury due to a press malfunction. After the incident, management investigates, installs emergency stop switches, and reinforces safety protocols.

Preventive Safety: Eliminating Risks Before They Occur

Preventive safety is a proactive strategy focused on reducing risks before they lead to incidents. It includes routine safety inspections, hazard assessments, employee training, and compliance with safety regulations.

Example in Manufacturing: A company installs pressure-sensitive safety guards, conducts regular machine inspections, and provides safety training, significantly reducing the risk of workplace injuries.

Key Differences Between Reactive & Preventive Maintenance

Factor	Reactive Maintenance	Preventive Maintenance
Approach	Fix after failure occurs	Scheduled servicing to prevent failures
Cost	Lower upfront, but high long-term	Higher upfront, but lower long-term
Downtime	Unplanned, disruptive	Controlled, minimal
Safety	Higher risk of failures	Proactively prevents hazards
Budget Planning	Unpredictable emergency costs	Predictable maintenance budget

Advantages & Disadvantages of Reactive Maintenance

✅ Advantages:

• Lower upfront costs – No scheduled servicing or monitoring investments.
• Simple execution – No need for extensive planning.
• Effective for low-cost assets – Works well for non-critical, inexpensive equipment.

❌ Disadvantages:

Safety risks – Malfunctions may lead to workplace accidents or regulatory fines.

Higher long-term costs – Emergency labor, expedited shipping, and part replacements.

Frequent downtime – Unexpected failures cause production halts and missed deadlines.

How to Measure Reactive vs. Preventive Maintenance Performance

📌 Key Maintenance Metrics to Track:

1. Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) – Measures the average time between equipment failures.
2. Mean Time to Repair (MTTR) – Tracks how long it takes to fix failed assets.
3. Planned vs. Unplanned Work Ratio – Compares scheduled vs. emergency maintenance tasks.
4. Total Maintenance Costs – Analyzes the impact of unplanned vs. planned maintenance expenses.
5. Equipment Downtime Percentage – Tracks the amount of time assets remain non-operational.

A higher ratio of planned maintenance and a lower MTTR indicate an effective preventive maintenance strategy.

---

Reactive vs. Preventive vs. Predictive Maintenance

🔹 Reactive Maintenance – Fix only after failure occurs.
🔹 Preventive Maintenance – Perform scheduled servicing to prevent failures.
🔹 Predictive Maintenance – Use sensor data & analytics to detect early warning signs before a failure happens.

🔍 Example Comparison:

• A factory conveyor belt breaks down unexpectedly → Reactive Maintenance
• A technician lubricates the conveyor belt monthly → Preventive Maintenance
• IoT sensors detect increased friction, triggering an alert → Predictive Maintenance

---

Reactive Maintenance Checklist

✅ Immediate Actions:

• Confirm the reported failure & assess its severity.
• Isolate the asset to prevent further damage.
• Determine if an emergency shutdown is required.

✅ Diagnosis & Troubleshooting:

• Identify the root cause of failure.
• Check equipment history in the CMMS.
• Verify spare parts availability for quick repairs.

✅ Repair & Documentation:

• Assign technicians based on priority level.
• Record all repair activities, including parts used.
• Update maintenance logs for future analysis.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Strategy

While reactive maintenance is useful in some cases, relying on it as a primary strategy increases long-term costs, risks, and operational disruptions. A balanced approach combining preventive, predictive, and reactive maintenance ensures optimal asset performance and cost efficiency.

📌 Next Steps: Start tracking maintenance performance metrics today and transition towards a data-driven maintenance strategy. 🚀

For a deeper dive into maintenance strategies, check out our related articles:

• Reactive Maintenance: When to Use It and Its Risks
• Preventive Maintenance: The Key to Reliability
• Predictive Maintenance: How to Stay Ahead of Failures